Leather cowboy hat beside a damp paddock

Leather Hat vs Oilskin Hat: Which Suits NZ Weather?

Choose an oilskin hat if rain is the main problem. Choose a leather hat if you want a firm shape, a long life and a look that gets better with wear. Oilskin is cotton cloth treated with oil, so it sheds showers and stays light. Leather is heavier and more rigid, and it handles wind, scrapes and sun well, but it needs more care when it gets soaked. Most Kiwis who wear hats outdoors all year end up with one of each.

This guide compares the two on the things that decide the purchase: rain, sun, comfort, weight, fit, durability and care. It also covers where each one fits in New Zealand life, from farm tracks to a wet walk to the bus stop.

Urbancaps
Find a Hat for NZ Weather
Compare leather and oilskin styles at Urbancaps to find headwear suited to your weather, outdoor plans and personal style.
Explore the hat collection

TL;DR

  • Oilskin is the better wet-weather hat: light, flexible and made to shed rain. Heavy, prolonged rain can still get through any oilskin.
  • Leather is the tougher, more structured hat: it holds its shape, suits wind and rough use, and develops a worn-in look. It is heavier and needs drying with care.
  • Sun: neither material does the job on its own. Brim width matters more than fabric, and a broad brim beats a cap.
  • Care: oilskin needs occasional re-proofing. Leather needs gentle cleaning, slow drying and conditioning.
  • Not sure? Pick by your worst regular day. Wet and mild means oilskin. Dry, windy or rough means leather.

Table of Contents

What is the difference between a leather hat and an oilskin hat?

The difference is the material, and the material decides everything else.

A leather hat is made from tanned animal hide. Cowhide, sheepskin and pigskin are common, and each feels different. Cowhide is stiff and hard-wearing. Sheepskin is softer and lighter. The hide is cut and sewn, or moulded, into a shape, so leather hats usually keep their form well.

An oilskin hat is made from cotton. The Cambridge Dictionary defines oilskin as cotton cloth with a thin layer of oil, intended to make it waterproof, and it includes hats made from the material. Te Ara, the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, describes oilskin the same way: cotton cloth impregnated with oil, and made into brimmed hats among other things. The hat is fabric, so it is softer and more packable than leather.

In short:

Leather hat Oilskin hat
Base material Tanned hide Cotton cloth treated with oil
Feel Firm, structured Soft, flexible
Weight Heavier Lighter
Wet weather Handles light rain, dislikes soaking Built to shed rain
Shape Holds its form Softer, can be packed down
Ageing Darkens and softens, develops patina Wears in, creases and fades at the folds
Upkeep Clean, dry slowly, condition Brush clean, re-proof when water stops beading

Rain: oilskin wins, with one honest limit

If you want a hat for a wet day, oilskin is the more obvious choice. The treatment is the whole point of the fabric. Te Ara notes that oilskin was a main waterproof material for rural New Zealand clothing before synthetic materials were developed, and that it was made into brimmed hats, jackets and leggings.

Oilskin Cap – Water-Resistant, Lightweight, Structured 6-Panel Fit

The same source is straight about its limits: heavy rain can still penetrate oilskin. That matches what most people find in practice. Water beads and runs off in a shower or a walk to the car. In a sustained downpour, water finds seams, stitching holes and the point where the hat sits on your head. Treat oilskin as water-resistant, not as a sealed shell.

Leather copes with light rain, especially if it is finished or oiled. But it takes up water when soaked. That is when problems start: it gets heavy, it can stain and it can stiffen as it dries. A leather hat is fine for drizzle on the way to work. It is not the hat to wear all day through a Fiordland downpour.

Rain performance comparison for leather and oilskin hats

If wet weather is your main concern, our guide to oilskin versus waxed cotton hats and how to look after them goes deeper on staying dry in NZ rain.

Sun: brim width matters more than material

New Zealand sun is a strong reason to wear a hat at all, and here the material is not the deciding factor. The shape is.

ARPANSA, Australia’s radiation protection agency, says broad-brimmed and wide bucket hats protect more areas of the face, ears and neck than caps. It also says hats rarely give enough protection on their own when sun protection is advised. So a hat is one layer, alongside shade, clothing and sunscreen.

Te Ara says broad-brimmed hats help keep off the sun, and it records renewed interest in broad brims because of awareness of sun-exposure risks. Both leather and oilskin come in wide-brim styles, so you can get good coverage from either.

A few practical points follow from that:

  • A wide-brim oilskin or leather hat shades far more skin than a baseball cap in either material.
  • A dark leather hat can feel hot in direct summer sun. A lighter-coloured or well-ventilated hat is more comfortable.
  • Check the ears and the back of the neck. A short brim at the back leaves them exposed.
  • If you work outside most days, add skin care on top of the hat. For example, sun protection built for outdoor workers covers the skin your brim leaves uncovered.

For more on picking a hat for sun and wind, see our guide to selecting outdoor headwear that works.

Comfort and breathability

Neither material is a summer fabric, but they behave differently.

Oilskin is a coated cotton. The coating that keeps rain out also slows the movement of air and moisture, so it can feel warm and slightly clammy in humid weather or when you are working hard. Many oilskin hats have eyelets or vents to help. Once broken in, the cotton base is soft against the head.

Leather is a natural material and can breathe somewhat better than a coated fabric, but it is also dense and holds heat. Unlined leather in full sun gets hot. A good lining and some ventilation make a large difference. Leather also warms to your body and moulds slightly to your head over time, which many wearers find more comfortable after a few weeks.

A simple rule: in cool, wet or windy weather, either works. In warm, still weather, choose a lighter colour, a vented crown and a brim that gives shade without sealing in heat.

Weight, fit and shape

Oilskin is the lighter option. A soft oilskin cap weighs very little, folds into a jacket pocket and sits easily under a hood. That makes it good for travel, tramping and anyone who takes a hat on and off all day.

Leather is heavier and firmer. That is a benefit if you want a hat that stays put in wind and does not flop, and it is a drawback if you are sensitive to weight on your head over a long day.

Fit is where leather needs more care when you buy:

  • Leather stretches slightly with wear, but does not give much at first. Buy a size that is snug but not tight. A hat that pinches on day one will not necessarily relax into comfort.
  • Oilskin cotton can tighten after a soaking and drying. Do not buy it very snug. It is easier to add a sweatband or adjust a strap than to stretch a hat that has shrunk.
  • Measure your head just above the eyebrows and ears with a soft tape, and check the size chart on the product page before ordering.
  • Check adjustability. A back strap or toggle lets you fine-tune the fit across seasons and with a beanie underneath.

For a structured, close fit, a six-panel oilskin cap gives you the oilskin weather resistance in a cap shape.

Durability: how long each one lasts

Both materials can last for years when looked after, and both can fail early when ignored.

Leather’s strengths are abrasion resistance and structure. It stands up to scrapes, scratches and being thrown on a ute seat. It does not tear easily. Its weak points are repeated soaking, heat and drying out. A leather hat left to dry by a heater can crack and warp.

Oilskin’s strengths are weather resistance and flexibility. Its weak points are the treatment itself and the folds. The oil or wax layer wears off along creases, at the brim edge and wherever the hat rubs. When that happens, water stops beading and starts soaking in. The fix is to re-proof it, not to replace the hat. Stiffening in cold weather and a slight tackiness in hot weather are normal for oil-treated cotton.

In plain terms: leather lasts longest in rough, dry use. Oilskin lasts longest in wet use, provided you re-treat it.

How to care for each hat

These are general care habits that apply to most hats of these materials. Always follow the care label or note on the product you buy, because finishes differ.

Oilskin hat care

  1. Shake off water and let the hat dry naturally, away from a heater, fire or direct sun. Heat can dry out the treatment.
  2. Brush off dried mud with a soft brush instead of rubbing it in wet.
  3. Avoid washing machines and strong detergents. They can strip the oil that makes the fabric shed water.
  4. Re-proof when water stops beading and soaks in. Clean the hat, let it dry fully, then apply a thin, even coat of a product made for oilskin and let it settle. Do it when performance fades, not on a fixed date.
  5. Store it loose in a dry spot with air around it, not crushed under heavy items.

Leather hat care

  1. Wipe with a soft, slightly damp cloth to remove dust and light marks.
  2. If it gets wet, blot it, stuff the crown with paper or a towel to keep its shape, and leave it to dry slowly at room temperature. No heaters, no hair dryers, no car dashboards.
  3. Condition it with a leather conditioner a few times a year, or when it looks dry or pale. Test on a hidden spot first.
  4. Keep it out of long, direct sun when you are not wearing it. Sun fades and dries leather.
  5. Store it on a shelf or hat stand, crown up, not squashed.

Our blog covers more on choosing outdoor hats and caring for them across the seasons.

Which one suits which situation in New Zealand?

Te Ara records that New Zealand rural hats have traditionally served both work and leisure. That is still true. The same hat often goes from the farm gate to the pub to the beach track. So think about where you actually spend your time.

Pick oilskin if you…

  • Live somewhere wet, such as the West Coast, Auckland in winter, or anywhere with changeable weather.
  • Walk, fish, fish from a boat, or spend time outdoors where a shower can arrive without warning.
  • Want something light that packs into a bag.
  • Prefer a casual, practical look.

Pick leather if you…

  • Want a hat that holds a sharp shape for years.
  • Work or play in rough conditions: fencing, stock work, gardening, hunting, or driving a tractor.
  • Like a style that ages visibly, with creases and a deeper colour over time.
  • Wear a hat for style as much as for weather, such as a western or cowboy look.

Pick one of each if you…

  • Have a wet-weather commute and a weekend outdoor life. Keep an oilskin cap by the door for rain and a leather hat for dry, dressier or rougher days.

If you wear hats across all four seasons, our guide to hats for Kiwi lifestyles lays out what to wear when.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Buying leather for a rainy daily commute. It will cope with a shower, but repeated soaking will age it faster.
  • Expecting oilskin to be fully waterproof. It is resistant, and heavy rain can still get in.
  • Drying either hat near heat. This is the fastest way to ruin both.
  • Choosing a cap when you need shade. A cap does not protect ears and neck the way a broad brim does.
  • Ignoring fit. A hat that is too tight gives headaches. One that is too loose blows off. Measure first.
  • Over-cleaning oilskin. Washing removes the treatment. Brush and spot clean instead.

Perspective: how we choose between the two

We are a New Zealand owned and operated store, and we sell hats to people who wear them hard. Our view is simple: the best material is the one that matches your worst regular day, not your best one.

We lean towards oilskin for anyone who gets caught out by rain often. It is light, it is easy to live with and it keeps a head dry in the sort of showers New Zealand throws up. We lean towards leather for people who want one hat to last, who are happy to look after it, and who like a hat that looks better in five years than it does on day one.

We would also say this: do not buy a hat for sun protection on material alone. Look at the brim first. A wide brim in either material beats a cap in both. And whichever you choose, spend ten minutes on care. Most hats we hear about failing were not badly made. They were dried on a heater or never re-treated.

— Urban

Shop leather and oilskin hats at Urban Caps

If you have decided which way to go, we stock both styles from our New Zealand base, with free shipping within NZ and AU. Each product page gives sizing and care details, and customer reviews help you see how a style wears in real life.

Oilskin Cap – Water-Resistant, Lightweight, Structured 6-Panel Fit

For rain, start with our oilskin cap, a lightweight, water-resistant, structured six-panel style. For leather, browse the men’s leather cowboy hat in a classic western shape, or the leather retro ethnic style western denim hat. To see everything, go to our leather caps and hats range. If you want shade, our bucket hats are a good place to start.

FAQ

Is a leather hat or an oilskin hat better in the rain?

Oilskin is better in the rain. It is cotton treated with oil to shed water, and it stays light when wet. Heavy, prolonged rain can still get through any oilskin, so it is water-resistant rather than fully waterproof. Leather handles light drizzle but can stain, stiffen and age faster if it is soaked repeatedly.

Is a leather cap good or bad?

A leather cap is good if you want durability, structure and a look that improves with age. It is a poor choice if you want something light, cool in summer or happy in constant rain. It also needs gentle care: slow drying away from heat, and occasional conditioning.

What is an oilskin cap?

An oilskin cap is a cap made from cotton cloth treated with oil to resist water. It is lighter and softer than leather and suits wet weather and general outdoor wear. Over time the treatment wears off, so you need to re-proof it when water stops beading on the surface.

Which hat gives better sun protection?

Neither material is better. Brim width decides it. Broad-brimmed and wide bucket hats cover more of the face, ears and neck than caps, and you should still use shade, clothing and sunscreen alongside any hat.

How often should I re-proof an oilskin hat?

There is no fixed schedule. Re-proof it when water stops beading and starts soaking into the fabric. How often depends on how much rain, sun and rubbing the hat gets. Clean it, let it dry fully, then apply a thin, even coat of a product made for oilskin.

Sources

Back to blog